Hockey-Stick discussions
hockeystickdiscuss.html
last update: 08Nov2007
Following the publication of von Storch in Science (October 2004), the discussions on the MBH98/99 temperature reconstruction is heating up considerably.
This page will be a starting block to make access to these discussions and papers easy...
Date | Author/Journal/Institution | Title | Comment |
08Nov07 | David Holland |
Bias and Concealment in the IPCC Process: The "Hockey-Stick" Affair and its Implications |
A reprint from Energy & Environment, vol. 18 No. 7+8 2007 |
22Jun06 | Hans von Storch et al | Press release ... NCR (NAS) report on past temperatures | |
14Nov05 | McKitrick and McIntyre | Why does the Hockey Stick Debate matter? | Read these contributions to R. Pielke's site Prometheus |
09Oct05 | Marcel Crok/Technology Review/Heise | Risse im Klimakonsens | German translation of the Dutch original article, with several comments by Cubasch, von Storch, Mann et. al. |
17 Jun 05 | Steve Mc.Intyre | Revisiting the stick | cristal clear article published in Toronto Financial Post |
23 Feb05 | Steve Mc.Intyre | Some Thoughts on Disclosure and Due Diligence in Climate Science | from http://www.climateaudit.org blog |
14Dec04 | www.co2science.org | More Problems for the Mann et al. Temperature Record | Discussion on : Rein, B., Luckge, A. and Sirocko, F. 2004. A major Holocene ENSO anomaly during the Medieval period. Geophysical Research Letters 31: 10.1029/2004GL020161. |
27Oct04 | Willie Soon/David Legates | Is the Hockey Stick Broken? | |
18Oct04 | McIntyre & McKitrick | Random numbers yield hockeystick | here is MM ongoing research page |
15Oct04 | Muller / MIT Technology Review | Global Warming Bombshell | On the McIntyre/McKitrick paper |
07Oct04 | Ahlbeck / climatesceptics mailing list | Comment | |
06Oct04 | www.co2andclimate.org | Ironies Abound in Hockey Stick Debacle | |
06Oct04 | Ahlbeck / climatesceptics mailing list | Comment | Swedish University of Finland |
01Oct04 | GKSS-Pressemitteilung | Temperaturschwankungen des letzten Millenniums... | in German |
30Sep04 | New Scientist news service | Models may underestimate climate swings | |
**Sep04 | McIntyre/McKitrick | M&M Project Update, September 2004 | An update to the ongoing discussion of the M&M paper (critical of MBH98) and Nature |
07Jul04 | www.globalwarming.org/Nature | 'Nature' corrects temperature record | A "forced" correction by
MBH in Nature. Click here for a pdf version of Mann's text in Nature |
******* | www.sciencedaily.com | Global Warming Controversy | A neutral report of arguments and standpoints |
07Jul03 | AGU (American Geophysical Union) | Leading Climate Scientists Reaffirm View that Late 20th Century Warming Was Unusual and Resulted From Human Activity | Statement by Mann et al. ...(after the Soon/Baliunas paper) |
23Apr1998 | Mann et al/ Nature | Original MBH98 paper | Nature Vol392 p.779-787 (23 April 1998) |